In a marathon meeting that lasted four hours, Plan Commission Chairman Howard Silver blasted remarks made by the library board’s president in the Glenview Announcements. Ellen Scholly reportedly implied that the village’s lengthy review process was driving the price of a new library up. “I don’t think the library board would be upset if either our owners’ representative or our architects slyly reminded the plan commission that they are running up our meter,” Scholly was quoted as saying.
“I would like to remind Mrs. Scholly and the library board of just who is running up the meter, “ Silver said. “It was this panel that insisted on reworking the traffic flow in the parking lot. Your experts had designed into the plan a number of potential conflicts that could result in head-on collisions and injured pedestrians. We also attempted to rework parts of the building so as to make it more inviting and less industrial looking.
“No, Mrs. Scholly,” he continued. “I don’t think it’s the plan commission that’s running up the meter. It’s a library board that won’t listen to the great majority of Glenview’s 44,000 citizens who say they don’t need or want a 93,000-square-foot edifice. It’s a library board that would design a huge, private second-floor board room for itself and generously-sized offices for its staff but will threaten equipping the new building with used furniture because of a crunch of funds. It’s a library board that has the audacity to put a For Sale sign on the library, much like Macy’s did to Marshall Fields and, God forbid, Sam Zell might do to Wrigley Field. That library’s name belongs to the people of Glenview, not to the highest bidder.
“And so as I open this case tonight, I invite, actually I dare the owner’s rep to come up here now and slyly remind us of how we are wasting your money. I will also remind Mrs. Scholly and the library board of one of those Confucian sayings that you can find in your own library stacks: ‘He who points a finger at someone else at the same time points three back at himself.’”
“Mr. Chairman, is that your statement?” said an uneasy Commissioner Allen Ruter.
Silver said it was.
“Certainly as the chair you have the prerogative to issue that statement, but you don’t speak for me, and I regret that you did that,” Ruter said. “We all have our feelings about the library, and I regret that a tone like this has been set before we have this very important discussion. I think the library staff and our board are acting out of sincerity and passion, and we certainly have had disagreements. I respect your right to have your opinion. It is, however, not mine.”
Silver said he felt obliged to speak because the plan commission had been publicly attacked.
Commissioner Steve Bucklin agreed with Ruter. “I never go into one of these meetings with an adversarial attitude. We’re all volunteers. We want what’s best for our community.” Then, in defense of the plan commission, he added, “Good things will take time to build, and I don’t believe anyone’s running up the meter on purpose.”
Not to be left out of the opening fireworks, Commissioner Peter Brinckerhoff said he didn’t agree with everything Silver had said, “but I am concerned if anybody thinks that our motivations are less than trying to get to the best possible project.”
Down to the Dull Details
The fireworks behind them, commissioners settled in for a presentation from the library’s architect. Randy Gibson described plans for a parking deck to provide 194-226 spaces. He had originally recommended 240 spots, but to reduce construction costs the library board scaled back.
Gibson tried to keep the commission’s focus on whether to build a two-story deck or a 1.5-story structure with the lower level below ground, but Brinckerhoff wouldn’t take the bait. “I appreciate that you’re trying to confine the argument,” he told Gibson, “but there is a broader question of whether we want a parking deck on Glenview Road.”
Gibson insisted it had to be built that way – with the new library facing Harlem – so the old building could be used while construction was underway. Chairman Silver thought maybe the library should move to the old Dominick’s site or to some other location so the new building could face on Glenview Road, and Brinckerhoff suggested the board build half the library at a time to eliminate the need for a move while providing a new building in the best possible location.
Discussion will continue at the plan commission’s next meeting, February 12. After Tuesday’s meeting, Ellen Scholly was overheard apologizing to Howard Silver. She said she had been misquoted by the Announcements